Dividend paying property and casualty insurance stocks
P&C insurers fund dividends from underwriting profit plus investment income on the float, which makes them one of the few groups that genuinely benefit from higher rates. Payout ratios are usually conservative.
38 operating companies currently paying a dividend, median yield 1.75%. Funds and ETFs are excluded on purpose — this is companies only. Prices as of Sep 3, 2026.
- 1ACICAmerican Coastal Insurance Corporation Common Stock6.73%
- 2AMSFAMERISAFE, Inc.6.25%
- 3GBLIGlobal Indemnity Group, LLC4.67%
- 4KMPRKemper Corporation4.46%
- 5DGICADonegal Group, Inc.4.06%
- 6CNACNA Financial Corporation3.95%
- 7SAFTSafety Insurance Group, Inc.3.57%
- 8DGICBDonegal Group, Inc.2.94%
- 9IFCZFIntact Financial Corporation2.88%
- 10HMNHorace Mann Educators Corporation2.80%
- 1CINFCincinnati Financial Corporation2.19% · payout 17%
- 2AFGAmerican Financial Group, Inc.2.45% · payout 32%
- 3ALLAllstate Corporation (The)1.66% · payout 8%
- 4HIGThe Hartford Insurance Group, Inc.1.73% · payout 16%
- 5THGHanover Insurance Group Inc1.67% · payout 18%
- 6SIGISelective Insurance Group, Inc.1.85% · payout 21%
- 7AIGAmerican International Group, Inc.2.60% · payout 34%
- 8TRVThe Travelers Companies, Inc.1.35% · payout 12%
- 9HMNHorace Mann Educators Corporation2.80% · payout 33%
- 10CNACNA Financial Corporation3.95% · payout 41%
- 1GBLIGlobal Indemnity Group, LLC22.9%/yr
- 2WRBW.R. Berkley Corporation21.8%/yr
- 3ACICAmerican Coastal Insurance Corporation Common Stock15.8%/yr
- 4AFGAmerican Financial Group, Inc.13.6%/yr
- 5KNSLKinsale Capital Group, Inc.13.6%/yr
- 6PGRProgressive Corporation (The)13.5%/yr
- 7ALLAllstate Corporation (The)13.1%/yr
- 8SIGISelective Insurance Group, Inc.10.8%/yr
- 9HIGThe Hartford Insurance Group, Inc.10.7%/yr
- 10IFCZFIntact Financial Corporation9.9%/yr
No company in this sector pays monthly — the quarterly cheque is the norm here. For monthly income, look at REITs, BDCs and specialty finance.
Specialty financeAll 38 p&c insurance dividend payers
38 shown · click any column to sort
| Company | Industry | Yield | Annual $ | Payout | Div growth | Streak | Quality | Size | 1Y |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chubb Limited | Property & Casualty Insurance | 1.20% | $4.08 | 14% | +4.3% | 31y | 39 | $131.1B | +22.1% |
Progressive Corporation (The) | Property & Casualty Insurance | 0.18% | $0.40 | 70% | +13.5% | — | 44 | $127.1B | -12.1% |
The Travelers Companies, Inc. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 1.35% | $5.00 | 12% | +5.2% | 21y | 73 | $77.2B | +32.2% |
Allstate Corporation (The) | Property & Casualty Insurance | 1.66% | $4.32 | 8% | +13.1% | 16y | 81 | $65.9B | +24.6% |
American International Group, Inc. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 2.60% | $2.00 | 34% | +6.5% | — | 75 | $40.2B | -6.8% |
HIGraised The Hartford Insurance Group, Inc. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 1.73% | $2.40 | 16% | +10.7% | 12y | 79 | $37.5B | +2.7% |
Intact Financial Corporation | Property & Casualty Insurance | 2.88% | $5.88 | 29% | +9.9% | 21y | 36 | $34.9B | -6.8% |
Cincinnati Financial Corporation | Property & Casualty Insurance | 2.19% | $3.76 | 17% | +7.7% | 66y | 90 | $26.4B | +10.0% |
WRBraised W.R. Berkley Corporation | Property & Casualty Insurance | 0.58% | $0.40 | 8% | +21.8% | 23y | 69 | $25.4B | -5.2% |
Loews Corporation | Property & Casualty Insurance | 0.23% | $0.25 | 3% | 0.0% | — | 46 | $22.4B | +12.1% |
Everest Group, Ltd. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 2.07% | $8.00 | 17% | +5.2% | 12y | 58 | $14.6B | +10.3% |
RenaissanceRe Holdings Ltd. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 0.50% | $1.64 | 3% | +2.7% | 31y | 65 | $13.8B | +35.0% |
CNAcut CNA Financial Corporation | Property & Casualty Insurance | 3.95% | $1.92 | 41% | +1.7% | 2y | 63 | $13.3B | -1.0% |
AFGcut American Financial Group, Inc. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 2.45% | $3.52 | 32% | +13.6% | 20y | 85 | $11.9B | +2.2% |
KNSLraised Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 0.26% | $1.00 | 3% | +13.6% | 10y | 63 | $8.7B | -18.8% |
Hanover Insurance Group Inc | Property & Casualty Insurance | 1.67% | $3.80 | 18% | +6.6% | 21y | 79 | $7.9B | +25.9% |
Axis Capital Holdings Limited | Property & Casualty Insurance | 1.77% | $1.76 | 13% | +1.3% | 12y | 30 | $7.3B | +1.9% |
RLIraised RLI Corp. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 1.12% | $0.72 | 14% | -84.8%† | 51y | 50 | $5.9B | -7.9% |
Mercury General Corporation | Property & Casualty Insurance | 1.21% | $1.27 | 8% | -12.8% | — | 21 | $5.8B | +32.5% |
SIGIraised Selective Insurance Group, Inc. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 1.85% | $1.72 | 21% | +10.8% | 11y | 78 | $5.6B | +13.8% |
White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 0.05% | $1.00 | — | 0.0% | — | 52 | $5.0B | +16.8% |
HCI Group, Inc. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 0.86% | $1.60 | 7% | 0.0% | 6y | 49 | $2.3B | +7.6% |
Horace Mann Educators Corporation | Property & Casualty Insurance | 2.80% | $1.44 | 33% | +3.1% | 18y | 68 | $2.1B | +8.5% |
Kemper Corporation | Property & Casualty Insurance | 4.46% | $1.28 | 178% | +1.3% | 4y | 12 | $1.7B | -48.2% |
Safety Insurance Group, Inc. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 3.57% | $3.68 | 87% | +0.2% | 9y | 48 | $1.5B | +41.2% |
UFCSraised United Fire Group, Inc. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 1.44% | $0.80 | 13% | +18.8%† | — | 51 | $1.4B | +76.1% |
UVEraised UNIVERSAL INSURANCE HOLDINGS In | Property & Casualty Insurance | 1.45% | $0.64 | 8% | 0.0% | — | 61 | $1.2B | +73.4% |
Maiden Holdings, Ltd. 6.625 NT 2046 | Property & Casualty Insurance | 15.84% | $1.66 | — | 0.0% | 2y | 7 | $919M | -34.0% |
Employers Holdings Inc | Property & Casualty Insurance | 2.77% | $1.36 | 278% | +4.7% | — | 15 | $883M | +14.5% |
Donegal Group, Inc. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 2.94% | $0.70 | 35% | +4.4% | 14y | 33 | $860M | +59.9% |
Donegal Group, Inc. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 4.06% | $0.77 | 41% | +3.9% | 11y | 44 | $714M | -0.1% |
Tiptree Inc. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 1.31% | $0.24 | 21% | +8.4% | — | 33 | $682M | -20.8% |
American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 24.00% | $4.08 | — | — | — | 39 | $509M | +32.5% |
AMERISAFE, Inc. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 6.25% | $1.64 | 65% | -19.4% | 12y | 48 | $487M | -45.0% |
American Coastal Insurance Corporation Common Stock | Property & Casualty Insurance | 6.73% | $0.75 | — | +15.8% | — | 34 | $451M | -18.2% |
Global Indemnity Group, LLC | Property & Casualty Insurance | 4.67% | $1.40 | 59% | +22.9% | 2y | 45 | $444M | +0.7% |
KINSraised Kingstone Companies, Inc. | Property & Casualty Insurance | 1.20% | $0.24 | 8% | — | — | 55 | $293M | +38.2% |
James River Group Holdings, Inc. Common Stock | Property & Casualty Insurance | 0.95% | $0.04 | 9% | -49.4% | — | 21 | $192M | -26.9% |
Operating companies only — ETFs, closed-end funds, ADRs and preferred shares or baby bonds are excluded. Payout ratio and raise-streak data isn't published for every company; blanks mean we don't have it rather than zero. * marks a 3-year growth rate where 5 years isn't available; † marks a 12-month growth rate shown because the longer rate is distorted by a stock split.
Other sectors
Go deeper
Frequently asked
How many p&c insurance stocks pay a dividend?
We currently track 38 p&c insurance operating companies paying a dividend, with a median yield of 1.75%. ETFs, closed-end funds and ADRs are excluded from this count — those are funds, not companies.
Which p&c insurance stock has the highest dividend yield?
ACIC shows the highest trailing yield in the sector at 6.73%. Treat the very top of any yield list with suspicion: an unusually high figure is often a special or one-off payment sitting in the trailing rate, or a share price that has collapsed.
Are high-yield p&c insurance dividends safe?
Yield alone tells you nothing about safety. In this sector 29 of 38 companies pay out 60% or less of earnings, which is the group with genuine room to keep raising. 2 have cut their dividend recently, and 8 have raised.
Do any p&c insurance companies pay monthly dividends?
No. Every dividend payer in this sector pays quarterly, semi-annually or annually. Monthly dividends are concentrated in REITs, BDCs and specialty finance.
How often is this list updated?
Nightly. Prices, yields, payout ratios and performance come from our own data pipeline, and this page reflects prices as of Sep 3, 2026. New dividend initiations and cuts are picked up automatically.
Disclaimer: The information provided on this website/service is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or legal advice. Investing in stocks involves high risk, including the loss of principal. We are not responsible for any financial losses or damages resulting from your reliance on this data. Always consult with a qualified financial professional before making investment decisions.
Trademark Notice: Twylight Crow's Dividend Tracker (formerly indexed as DiviDrip) is an independent portfolio utility. This tool is not affiliated with, authorized, endorsed by, or in any way officially connected to Dividrip.com or its international affiliates.